Victor A. Montemurro
Comprehensive Digital Portfolio
St. John's University School of Education
EDU 5419: Advanced Study in Organizational Theory
Professor Frank L. Smith, Jr., Ed.D.
on the myrtle flower to jump to
Bryk, A. S. & Schneider, B. (2002). Trust in schools:
A core resource for improvement. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
The authors present the grounded theory of relational trust that developed as a result of research on the Chicago School Reform Act. The author's sought to explore the following central question:
What does it mean at the school site to implement a reform policy of decentralization with parent empowerment?
The Chicago School Reform Act called for the
establishment of Local School Council six parents, two community members and two
teachers. Also included was the principal and a high school student for
secondary schools. The Local School Council, an elected body, was given
wide-ranging authority for the governance of the school including the hiring and
firing of school principals and allocation of funds.
Trust in Schools is based on the above study served as the major study effort of the course. The grounded theory of relational trust was aligned with other frameworks for studying organizational culture previously considered. Relational trust is essentially a sociological framework that may be applied to organizations and aligned with the structural, human relations, political, and cultural lenses for the study of organizations. The following criteria for discernment may be examined to assess the degree of relational trust in an organization: respect, competence, personal regard for others, integrity. A healthy organization, such as functional professional community (Newmann & Wehlage, 1995) will most likely exhibit a high degree of relational trust. The frame of relational trust may be added to Bolman & Deal's (1997) four frame view that includes the political, the human resource, the structural, and the symbolic frames.
The trust frame was personally engaging to me as a theory of human relationship in the organization as building trust was always an element of classroom interaction that I found essential to the development of readers and, in particular, beginning writers. Trust as a concept, and in the form of specific exercises and games, also played a role in my work with theater ensembles. Intelligent and creative working together and artistic expression depend upon trust as an inherent value in the creative process.
Chronology of the study based on Professor Smith's notes
Ridgeway Elementary School Case Multiple Frame Analysis
Trust In Schools Outline
Cohort members also completed the following multiple frame analyses of two other schools featured in Chapters 4 and 5 of the text:
School: Cultural Diversity as an Obstacle to Trust
Holiday Elementary School: Dedicated to the Welfare of Children
Both documents below are available from the Northwest
Regional Educational Laboratory:
Building Trusting Relationships for School Improvement: Implications for Principals and Teachers, (September, 2003)
Building Trust With
Schools and Diverse Families: A Foundation for Lasting Partnerships,
|SJU School of Education Comprehensive Digital Portfolio||Copyright 2004 by Victor A. Montemurro. All right reserved.|